Administrative law · Core
M-01 — Vavilov reasonableness review, from first principles
CPD · Structured · Ethics & Professional Responsibility
4 hr
A working RCIC reading of Canada (Minister of Citizenship and Immigration) v. Vavilov, 2019 SCC 65 — what "reasonableness" actually demands, how it plays at RAD / IAD / ID, and how to write a memorandum that survives a Federal Court JR.
Lessons
- 01What Dunsmuir got wrong and Vavilov fixedReading25m
- 02The reasonableness spine — justification, transparency, intelligibilityReading20m
- 03Scenario: RAD appeal on implausibility without ValtchevScenario90m
- 04Rubric debrief — what the AI officer scored and whyDebrief30m
- 05Self-check — draft a Vavilov paragraph, get it gradedRubric30m
Outcomes
- ✓Name the four constraints on reasonable decision-making
- ✓Spot implausibility findings that fail Vavilov
- ✓Write a JR-ready reasonableness paragraph in under 20 min
